In the past decade, litigation
alleging inadequate security has become one of the fastest
growing areas of business lawsuits.
If you are an owner and/or manager of a
hotel/motel, apartment complex, shopping center, office building,
convenience store, hospital or other business where public
access is allowed, then your risk of being sued for crimes
committed against your customers, guests, tenants or other
invitees is dramatically increased.
There are five major areas which have effected
the explosive growth of premises security lawsuits:
- The dramatic increase of crime across
the nation.
- Highly publicized cases involving
million dollar plus awards.
- Catastrophic physical injuries to
crime victims.
- Long term psychological effects of
crime victims.
- The increase in the victims rights
movement.
Violent crimes have increased during the
past decade by 33.7%. The violent crimes associated most
commonly with civil litigation increased as follows:
- Murder - Increased by 4.1%
- Robbery - Increased by 7.8%
- Rape - Increased by 24.3%
- Aggravated Assault -Increased by 58.9%
During the past two years premises security
cases have been reported with verdicts or settlements as
follows:
- $54 Million for a victim of an armed
robbery in the parking lot of a shopping center
- $14 Million for a rape victim while
a tenant of an apartment complex
- $10 Million for a rape victim while
a guest of a motel
- $2.75 Million for a victim of an assault
while a patron of a bar.
In addition to the media coverage these
cases received major networks such as ABC's "20/20", "CBS
News", CNN's "Larry King Live" and "Inside
Edition" have aired investigative reports or news stories
on crime victims and premises security litigation.
To determine if security measures are reasonable,
the following questions must be answered:
- What type of crime area is your business
located in?
- What types of crimes have occurred
on the premises of your business?
- Are you aware of all the crimes that
have occurred on your premises?
- Do you know the extent that the local
police patrol your premises
- Do you maintain a good liaison with
the local police department?
- Have you ever taken advantage of "free" advice
from the local police department's crime prevention unit?
- Are you taking reasonable steps to
control access onto your premises?
- Is the lighting on your premises adequate?
- Are locks and other physical security
measures adequate and in good working order?
- Are your security personnel properly
trained?
- Are you properly documenting and maintaining
security related incident reports?
- Are all your employees made aware
of any crimes that occur on your premises?
- Do employee meetings include security
topics as well as other business related topics?
- Do you have training programs which
emphasize security responsibilities for each employee?
- Does your corporate "philosophy" include
the security and safety of your customers, guests, tenants
or invitees?
Practical Suggestions to Avoid Liability
The following suggestions are practical
measures which a business owner and/or manager may take to
limit their exposure to premises security lawsuits. These
measures will also prove to be very helpful in the defense
of such suits.
- Have a written security plan and conduct
periodic reviews and revisions.
- Have written security policies and
procedures for your employees. Consider having them sign
an acknowledgment that they have read and have gone over
with you the company's security policies. Place that
documentation in their personnel folder.
- Make sure that your hiring and selection
process includes thorough reference checks, including
inquiry into any lapse of time on their application.
- Do not make false, misleading or absolute
statements about the security of your premises (e.g., "totally
safe", "guaranteed secure").
- Ensure your security procedures and
programs are state of the art and reflect the highest
current "level of care" in your neighborhood
or geographic area.
- Periodically alert tenants to ways
to protect themselves, including crime trends and security
programs that you have implemented to protect their welfare.
- Ensure all security devices are maintained
and repaired in a timely manner. It is recommended that
an inspection of security breaches, safety concerns or
repairs be done on a daily basis.
- Know what security measures may be
unique to your industry and follow them.
- Make sure lighting is adequate and
bushes are trimmed where intruders or attackers could
hide.
- React immediately to any crimes which
occur on your premises offer the victim(s) as much assistance
a possible until professional help can arrive
- Seek advice from trade organizations
or security consultants in your area if you have security
concerns.
- Encourage the local police to patrol
your premises as frequently as possible throughout the
daylight, evening and early morning hours...consider
putting this in writing as this and any documentation
can be a valuable piece of evidence if litigation develops.
|