In today's headlines, articles
about employees being assaulted and murdered in the workplace
are appearing more frequently. Historically, this threat
of bodily harm and possible psychological trauma came from
outsiders (e.g., during holdups). Today, more and more, we
find it comes from within through a co-worker or a spouse.
This article will deal with potential violence in the workplace
from insiders.
A 1993 Northwestern National Life Insurance
survey estimated that 2.2 million Americans were attacked
at work during the preceding 12 months and that another 6.3
million were threatened. One out of 12 Human Resources managers
responding to an American Management Association Survey last
year stated that at least one violent workplace death had
occurred within their organization in the past 4 years. This
same survey found that 35.4 percent reported some kind of
violent incident since the beginning of 1990. One third of
the respondents said they had more than one violent workplace
incident since 1989. One of every four managers said their
organizations had experienced a threat of violence; 17.3
percent reported at least one incident of employees suffering
post-traumatic stress. One of every 10 managers reported
at least one injury resulting in hospitalization and 15.3
percent reported less serious injuries.
For over 100 years the U.S. has had a higher
incident rate of violence in the workplace than other developed
nations. The Justice Department reports that nearly one million
violent crimes--or almost one-sixth of all reported violent
crimes in the country--occur in the workplace. It estimates
that 8 percent of rapes, 7 percent of robberies and 16 percent
of assaults occur in the workplace yearly. Workers have a
one in four chance of being the victim of some form of violence
at work.
Most homicides occur among friends, relatives
and acquaintances, and violence among co-workers is on a
steady rise. Most of these homicides result from arguments
or disputes between two people who know each other well,
such as co-workers. A seemingly simple verbal conflict eventually
escalates into a violent act. In many instances, those who
witness adversarial verbal exchanges fail to see the danger
of the situation, the problem remains and violence eventually
ensues.
The National Institute for Occupational
Safety and Health (NIOSH) reports that violence specifically
directed against employers and employees by other employees
is now the fastest growing category of homicide in the U.S.
From 1980-1989 nearly 12% of workplace deaths were classified
as homicides. This was the third leading cause of death in
the workplace. Data also reveals that homicide is the leading
cause of death for women in the workplace accounting for
42% of all on the job fatalities.
NIOSH figures show that 17% of on the job
fatalities in 1992 were attributed to homicide. During that
year alone, approximately 111,000 incidents of workplace
violence were reported. Not only did these incidents result
in 1,072 deaths and thousands of injuries, but also an estimated
4.2 billion dollars in related costs for employers.
Workplace violence, particularly that perpetrated
by one worker against a co-worker or management, rarely occurs
without warning signs or symptoms:
WARNING SIGNS
There are common signals and causes that
may often precede most violent acts:
- Verbal disputes that aren't settled
and escalate (often two persons who know each other). Disputes
are often trivial in nature (employer-employee arguments
over business relationships).
- Person that sees themselves as the victim.
- Dispute pattern builds and intensifies.
- Victim engages in provocative behavior
that they don't often realize, and trigger the attack.
- Violence is often preceded by feelings
of resentment, jealousy, helplessness.
- Anger and extreme stress are clearly
visible in the person’s demeanor.
- Threats, intimidation, verbal challenge
and insulting comments from the attacker occur.
- Violence is often preceded by acts of
pushing or other physical contact by the attacker/ victim.
- Substance abuse contributes greatly
to the possibility of violence.
- Unusual/changed behavior
- Unshakable depression
RECOGNIZING THE SYMPTOMS
- Go with your "GUT FEELING" (each
employee knows what is acceptable behavior)
- Take note of verbal threats against
yourself, other employees or management.
- Recognize the person with an "unnatural
intensity of feelings", hurts (real or imagined) fester
and grow in that person's mind.
- Persons that are totally convinced they
are right are difficult to reason with and often times
will not accept normal methods of seeking redress
- Substance abuse and alcoholism can be
contributors to violence, recognize the symptoms.
- ersons who see conspiracies everywhere,
such as, 'everyone in the company is out to get me' should
have their behavior monitored.
- atch for vandalism and theft.
- Are you receiving threatening e-mail,
notes on your desk, threats on voice mail or hang-ups and
or silence on the phone line?
WHAT THE VICTIM SHOULD DO
- Notify your supervisor if you are a
victim of threats (trust your instincts!!!).
- Document all incidents, save any evidence.
- Don't challenge unstable persons; let
management's crisis intervention team deal with it.
- Do not ignore threats whether verbal
or physical in nature (they will only escalate). Recognize
changes in your co-workers behavior.
- Avoid working alone after hours until
the issue is resolved.
- If an incident with a co-worker has
occurred, take notice of any vandalism to your work area.
- Advise your supervisor if you’re
having spousal difficulties that you fear could escalate
so that company can take security precautions.
When these or other signs and symptoms are
present, there are reasonable measures that potential victims
and management can take to help lesson the potential for
violence in the workplace.
MANAGEMENT'S RESPONSIBILITY
Key factors are early awareness and effective,
professional management of conditions before problems arise.
Potentially violent interpersonal events are usually predictable.
Training in perception and awareness can help managers recognize
and manage these volatile situations.
- Clearly communicate senior management's
decisive stance of zero tolerance for harassment or workplace
violence.
- Educate employees about the issue, including
the nature and availability of the company's training program
(address dangerous conditions), and how to report incidents.
- A true, open-door mentality has to be
created for people in the office or assembly line who will
be the first ones on notice.
- Management should establish an atmosphere
of "team effort" to encourage all employees to
be involved.
- Establish a confidential employee assistance
program (EAP) to allow employees with personal problems
to seek professional help.
- Establish people-sensitive processes
for potentially negative circumstances, such as termination
and or downsizing.
- Consult with your safety professional
for suggestions on premises security (including controlled
access, personnel identification policies and procedures,
equipment and facility design, background checks (criminal
records check where appropriate), and sensitivity and nonforce
conflict resolution training to security personnel, checks
of employees, and providing a safe work environment under
the General Duty Clause of OSHA.
- Supervisor training in conflict management
should be provided to recognize the potentially dangerous
employee and to take action when appropriate. They must
also be trained to show sensitivity to any concerns raised
by employees and a willingness to address them.
- Establish an 'intervention team' to
address employee concerns. Team should be comprised of
management and line staff.
- The intervention team can interview
the victim, any witnesses and be prepared to deal with
the situation.
- Finally, the intervention team should
perform a 'fitness-for-duty' evaluation and make recommendations
to management.
The experts will tell you that preventing
violence in the workplace has nothing to do with luck and
everything to do with good planning. The single biggest deterrent
is to avoid hiring your problems in the first place through
good hiring practices. This means making thorough background
checks, calling references and prior employers, questioning
all gaps in employment and trusting your gut feelings.
|